-
Joy is in the ears that hear: Grammar Nazi's
I know you think that correcting people makes you look really clever; using a set of rules that must have been made by a God to be oh so important and restrict creativity and try and…
The plural of ‘nazi’ example is funny because it actually has nothing to do with grammar. It has to do with writing conventions. And that is a common problem - equating speech with writing. Writing is secondary to speech.
Think about it: how do you pronounce ‘nazi’s’ versus ‘nazis’? The exact same. Now, if you were to say ‘nazi’ as the plural, then that would be incorrect as far as descriptive English rules go. The funny thing is, though, that a native English speaker wouldn’t say that, just like they would never say ‘a the man’. There’s a big difference between that and, say, splitting an infinitive.
Ahh, a futile battle. Until people start thinking.
Posted on December 17, 2011 via Bunny Brain with 35 notes
Source: lokidanu
-
ieithoedd liked this
-
aquaribbon liked this
-
ashlita liked this
-
lesserjoke reblogged this from illustratedjai and added:
That’s exactly my feeling, too. I mean, let’s be clear: Holocaust/Nazi metaphors are almost always misplaced, because...
-
videogamejunkiee liked this
-
lesserjoke reblogged this from andurrs
-
spaceconfessional reblogged this from andurrs and added:
Hikki, your blog challenges my views on how I write every single day and I love you all the more for it.
-
andurrs reblogged this from lesserjoke and added:
didyoudrinkmygingerale is my new tumblr crush, and as usual everything lesserjoke says is flawless
-
illustratedjai reblogged this from lesserjoke and added:
I’m with lesserjoke here - There was a description in the early conversation about not accepting the ways in which...
-
allthegirlsarebummers liked this
-
lesserjoke reblogged this from johnnyunger and added:
There we’ll have to disagree, I’m afraid. I think it’s far more unsettling for someone to self-identify as a Nazi (any...
-
iguanaco liked this
-
johnnyunger reblogged this from lesserjoke and added:
I don’t see that there’s a huge difference in whether people trivialize Nazism by using the label for someone they...
-
lesserjoke reblogged this from johnnyunger and added:
That’s a fair point, and one I’ve addressed in part before now. As I mention in that blog post, “grammar nazi” is a term...
-
lokidanu reblogged this from johnnyunger and added:
term entirely inappropriate....called themselves “grammar police” or “sticklers
-
johnnyunger reblogged this from lesserjoke and added:
What I find offensive about this is not the use of an apostrophe. It’s that in the whole discussion no one has reflected...
-
lesserjoke reblogged this from vulgarieloquentia and added:
Spoken language and written language are different, but each is still language. Each is an ordered presentation of words...
-
vulgarieloquentia reblogged this from lesserjoke and added:
‘nazi’ example...funny because it actually has nothing to do with
-
lokidanu reblogged this from nothingrhymeswithmammoth and added:
“not all change is good” - “some change is bad” and “I am deciding that some change is bad”. When in some peoples eyes...
-
nothingrhymeswithmammoth reblogged this from lokidanu and added:
I’d reply to the three reblogs I got on that post, but being called “not very clever” just put me off the idea. Yes, I...
-
lokidanu reblogged this from lesserjoke and added:
say I particularly liked yours....very interesting replies
-
neanderkrawl liked this
-
lesserjoke reblogged this from didyoudrinkmygingerale and added:
I know I’ve been posting my own responses to this issue already, but this is a great answer too!
-
lokidanu reblogged this from nothingrhymeswithmammoth and added:
have just presumed that I think grammar is completely pointless and that I think that...be...
-
didyoudrinkmygingerale reblogged this from nothingrhymeswithmammoth and added:
My first is in response to you saying “without structure things would go awry.” What things? Where does this structure...
-
lesserjoke reblogged this from nothingrhymeswithmammoth and added:
Objectively speaking, language change is neither good nor bad. What it is is socially motivated. Language changes...
-
franco-ontarienne reblogged this from lesserjoke
-
nothingrhymeswithmammoth reblogged this from didyoudrinkmygingerale and added:
I have to disagree. You can’t disguise all of bad grammar as creativity. You can play around with word order all you...
-
makethissound reblogged this from yesterdaybells
-
didyoudrinkmygingerale reblogged this from lokidanu
-
lesserjoke reblogged this from yesterdaybells and added:
PLURAL God damn it, yes it does and that was the goddamn point of this goddamn post. Language is only and completely...
-
higuysitsalex liked this
-
yesterdaybells reblogged this from lesserjoke and added:
GOD DAMN IT APOSTROPHE S DOES NOT MAKE THINGS PLURAL. APOSTROPHE S DOES NOT MAKE THINGS PLURAL. APOSTROPHE S DOES NOT...
-
lesserjoke reblogged this from lokidanu and added:
Seriously! Everyone’s...perfect, no matter what. Holding people’s grammar up against
-
lokidanu posted this
-